Jake McCluskeyStand Your Watch
← All posts
Behind the Armor4 min read

Feeling Nothing Isn't Strength. It's a Warning.

Behind the Armor brand card on the Stand Your Watch paper ground

There's a man everyone admires. Nothing rattles him. Bad news, good news, a crisis, a funeral, and his face doesn't move. He's steady, they say. Solid. The rock. And somewhere along the way he decided that was the goal, that a real man is a man who feels as little as possible, and he's spent years sanding down every reaction until there's almost nothing left to move.

I want to say the hard thing to that man, because I've been closer to him than I'd like. What you're calling strength might be a slow death. Feeling nothing is not the same as being at peace. A lot of the time, it's the warning light for a heart that's shutting down.

Understand what numbness actually is. It is not the absence of pain. It's the presence of so much pain, for so long, that a man's heart threw the breaker to stop the overload. It's a survival move, and it works, for a while. You stop hurting. But you don't get to choose what goes numb. A heart that can't feel the bad can't feel the good either. The same wall that keeps out the grief keeps out the joy, the wonder, the love, the conviction. You wanted to stop hurting and you accidentally stopped living, and now you sit at your own kid's birthday feeling like you're watching it through glass.

God does not describe the numb heart as strong. He describes it as stone, and He treats it as something that needs replacing. "I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit within you; and I will remove the heart of stone from your flesh and give you a heart of flesh" (Ezekiel 36:26). Read what God calls the hard, unfeeling heart. Stone. And read what He promises to do with it. Not reinforce it. Not admire it. Remove it, and hand you back a heart of flesh, a heart that can be moved, a heart that can hurt and love and break. God's rescue is not a tougher stone. It's a softer heart. The thing you've been building, He came to take away.

The New Testament has a chilling phrase for where the numbing road ends. Paul describes men who "having become callous, have given themselves over to sensuality" (Ephesians 4:19). Callous. Past feeling. He's not describing wild sinners. He's describing men who went numb, and he names it as the danger, not the defense, because a man who can't feel anymore will eventually reach for anything that makes him feel something, and it's usually the thing that costs him everything.

Here's the part that should really stop a religious man. Jesus reserved some of His sharpest words not for the men who felt too much but for the ones who felt nothing. "So because you are lukewarm, and neither hot nor cold, I will spit you out of My mouth" (Revelation 3:16). Lukewarm. Room temperature. The man who's stopped running hot for anything, who's managed his heart down to a flat, safe, unbothered nothing, and Jesus says that flatness makes Him sick. We tend to think the danger is feeling too much. He says the danger is a heart gone cold enough that nothing reaches it anymore.

I know how a man gets here, because it isn't laziness. It's usually loss. He felt something once, and it wrecked him, so he decided never again. He grieved and nobody helped him carry it, so he sealed the room. He got his heart broken and swore off the whole business of being moved. The numbness isn't weakness of character. It's an old wound that scarred over the whole surface. But a scar you can live behind is still a scar you're living behind, and God wants you out of there.

This is where a man has to do the thing that feels backward. The way out of numbness is not more control. It's the opposite. It's letting yourself feel the thing you sealed off, on purpose, in the presence of God who can handle it. The grief you never grieved. The loss you never named. Bring it up out of the basement into the light and let it hurt, because a wound that finally gets to hurt is a wound that can finally heal, and a heart that starts to ache again is a heart coming back to life. David wasn't numb. Read the Psalms, the man felt everything, at full volume, in front of God, and God called him a man after His own heart. Not a man who felt nothing. A man who brought all of it to the throne.

Do this. Sit somewhere quiet, no phone, and ask God one question you've been avoiding: what have I stopped letting myself feel? Then don't run from the answer when it comes. If grief rises, let it. If it's been years since you cried and something in your throat tightens, that's not weakness, that's the stone starting to crack, and that crack is God keeping His promise. A heart of flesh is coming back. Let it.

The unmovable man isn't the strong one. He's the one in the most danger, because he can't feel how far he's drifted. Come back to feeling. It's where God can reach you.

Before you go

Not sure how to pray?

Nine short prayers for a man in a hard moment, plus one in your inbox every Thursday. Free, and yours to keep.

Keep reading