Jake McCluskeyStand Your Watch
← All posts
Culture War4 min read

Which Jesus Are They Talking About

Branded card for the post "Which Jesus Are They Talking About".

Some lies wear a costume. They borrow the words you grew up on, the hymns, the name above every name, and they slide something else in behind it while you are busy nodding along. That kind is hard to catch. You have to slow down and check the label.

This one is not that. This one walks right up to the counter and tells you what it is.

"For if one comes and preaches another Jesus whom we have not preached, or you receive a different spirit which you have not received, or a different gospel which you have not accepted, you bear this beautifully." (2 Corinthians 11:4)

Paul saw it in the first century. A man stands up wearing spiritual authority, a title, a robe, the trust of people who came to hear about God. He says the name Jesus. And the Jesus he hands you is not the one the Bibles in the pews are talking about.

Picture it plainly. A man carries the title of archbishop. He denies that Christ is God. He denies that Christ was sinless. He denies that Christ died for anyone's sins. He denies that Christ rose from the dead. He denies that Christ saves. He denies that Christ is the only way to the Father. And then, with all of that stripped away, he keeps the name. He tells you Jesus was a good man whose real message was mostly "love one another," and he calls that Christianity.

Brother, that is not a smaller version of the faith. It is a different faith wearing the faith's clothes.

Here is the thing men miss. Christianity is not a buffet where you keep the parts of Jesus you find agreeable and quietly leave the rest on the tray. Nobody gets to build a Christ out of the traits that flatter him. Paul did not warn about a slightly-off Jesus. He warned about another Jesus, a whole different one, handed over under the same three letters.

So the real question is never "does this man admire Jesus." Plenty of men admire an idea of Jesus. The question is which Jesus he means.

Walk the dominoes with me, because once the first one goes, they all go.

If Jesus is not God, then He cannot be the Christ that Scripture actually reveals. The whole book is built on Him being God with us, not a wise carpenter with good lines.

If Jesus was sinful, then He cannot be the spotless sacrifice. A lamb with a blemish gets rejected at the altar. A Savior with sin of His own has nothing left over to pay for yours.

If Jesus did not bear your sins, then the cross is just a Roman execution with a good man on it, and it saves no one. It is tragedy, not rescue.

If Jesus did not rise, the whole thing is finished. Paul said it himself, if Christ has not been raised then our preaching is worthless and so is your faith. A dead teacher stays dead and cannot carry you anywhere.

And if Jesus is not the only way to the Father, then Jesus was lying. Because He is the one who said it, not a pushy street preacher, not a denomination.

"Jesus *said to him, 'I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father but through Me.'" (John 14:6)

You cannot call Him a good man and call that sentence false in the same breath. A good man does not stand in front of the world and claim to be the only road to God if He is not. That is not humility with a nice message about love. That is the biggest lie a man could tell. So either He is exactly who He said, or the "good teacher" version collapses the moment you read His own words.

Now let me be honest with you about the turn my heart takes here, because I do not want you to hear this wrong.

I do not read about a man teaching this and feel some kind of win. I do not rejoice. I read it and I am afraid for him.

Think about what that man is doing. He is standing in a place of spiritual authority, in front of people who trust him, and he is publicly telling them a Christ who cannot save them. Scripture does not treat that lightly. Teachers are told they will be judged more strictly, and the ones who lead people away from the true Christ are not handed a lighter load for meaning well. That is a heavy place to be standing. I would not want to be there for anything.

So my prayer for a man like that is the same prayer I would want somebody praying for me if I had wandered that far. That God would break through the title and the robe and the applause. That he would meet the real Christ, the God who became sin's cure, who died and got back up, who is the only way home, while there is still time to turn around. Repentance is open to an archbishop the same as it is open to you.

You do not need a seminary degree to protect yourself from this. You need to know which Jesus you are being handed.

So do one thing today. Open to John 14 and read it slow, out loud if you can, until verse 6 lands on you as the words of the only man with the right to say them. Then the next time someone offers you a Jesus, you will already know the one to ask for.

Before you go

Not sure how to pray?

Nine short prayers for a man in a hard moment, plus one in your inbox every Thursday. Free, and yours to keep.

Keep reading